Rob Bell is a minister in Grand Rapids, MI and is an individual that has greatly shaped my faith and my thought process and how I live my life today. He's written several great books and I would highly recommend and encourage you to read his books. This is an interview that he did with YouthWorker Journal, have a read and give me your thoughts.
YouthWorker Journal: What are some specific tools youth pastors need for effective ministry? Back in my day, if you could play guitar (you needed to know chords C, F and G, but not much more) and could lead kids in wacky games, you pretty much got the job. If you could provide an insight into a Bible verse at the end of some activity, well then, you were gold. What are the magic bullets for today's youth minister?
Rob Bell: I don't begin to think about that by wondering, "How do you do youth ministry?" I begin with, "What kind of person are you?" Let's explore your own experience with the resurrected Christ. So if a youth pastor says, "How do I create a safe place where my kids can deal with their pain?" Let's first talk about your own parents' divorce. Let's talk about how Christ is helping put you back together. A lot of times we've been burned because even if someone could play the guitar and got the job, then it turned out the person had a lot of other stuff he or she was carrying. Who doesn't have some story of a person they respected having a massive collapse spiritually, emotionally, sexually, whatever?
YWJ: OK, the magic bullets, if you don't mind.
RB: The dominant paradigm in churches is production, not discipleship. It's about how to keep kids coming—how are the numbers? In the gospels, whenever there were large crowds, Jesus gave a difficult teaching that thinned out the crowd. Over and over, He chose those moments: John 6—Unless you eat my flesh and drink my blood. Nice. Very accessible for kids. There is a certain pattern where He's trying to find out who is serious. Youth workers are put in this position where their paychecks are based on how many people they can keep in the place. When they read the gospels, they realize this whole system seems to be going the other direction. Many youth pastors I've met are promoting something they don't believe.
YWJ: Could we get back to the professionalism part of youth ministry and how to get thousands of kids to come to our youth programs?
RB: I work from a different assumption. My assumption is that the real issues are about the interiors and not the exteriors. What the past couple of hundred years have done, with the invention of machines and mechanisms where you push a button pull a lever, is that it created metaphors of production and industry that are applied to matters of the spirit. So in youth ministry, we ask: How do you grow a youth ministry? How do you reach kids? What external techniques, skills and strategies do I need for doing A and B so I can get to C? The real issues are first and foremost about your own interiors, your own following of Jesus, the way in which the Spirit of God is healing you of all sorts of things. The ways in which you are experiencing the resurrected Christ in a thousand different places.
YWJ: Why do so many youth pastors start strong and then burn out?
RB: This goes back to a production understanding versus discipleship. When Jesus dealt with crowds, He would then withdraw to a lonely place and pray. As the crowds increased, His rhythm of engagement and disengagement seemed to increase. In our culture, the larger the crowds, the harder you gotta work. When you move from a production model to discipleship, one of the questions becomes: Is this sustainable? Am I leading the kind of life in which I'm experiencing and living the things I'm inviting others to experience?YWJ: What would that kind of disengagement look like today?
RB: Well, experiencing Sabbath is one example. It's a lost art. There is a reason why these ancient disciplines are absolutely necessary. Just ask your average youth pastor, "What day of the week do you not answer your cell phone and not answer email?" When they say, "What do you mean?" Then I say, "Call me in four years when you burn out." Rabbi Heschel said that Sabbath gives the world the spiritual energy it needs to exist for another six days. There is something very mystical and practical about disciplines such as the Sabbath and about centering prayer. These all clash with the gods of production.
YWJ: How do you personally keep from buying into those gods of production?
RB: I have very strong boundaries. There are thousands of things I don't do. My wife and I are ruthless about sustainability. I would tend to just go all the time, so this has been a bit of the journey for me. Saturday is the Sabbath, and I make the boys breakfast and pack their lunches, and we have dinner together every night. I haven't done a pastors' conference in years. God is down in the valley, as well as on the mountaintop; and actually the valley is where we live. This idea that God is to be found up there, well, to me, God is found in making lunches for your kids, driving them to school and helping them with homework; making pasta and taking the dog in the woods with us.
YWJ: So, celebrating the Sabbath is a tool for ministry?
RB: If you're busy, fried and a wreck, who wants your gospel?
YWJ: You're big on mystery, wonder and mysticism. Can that work in youth ministry? Will kids stay on track if you go there?
RB: They're much more in tune. It's when you get older that you believe you can figure all this out. I think a kid fundamentally understands there's a God who made everything, something is happening and history is headed somewhere; and they understand that it's awe-inspiring and amazing. They would be OK with language failing.
YWJ: Aren't they looking for answers? At least in school there are answers.
RB: I was bored out of my mind in school: Here's the answer, OK. What's the next answer? OK, I got it. Then they meet somebody who's awe-inspiring, such as Bishop Tutu. They resonate with that.
YWJ: So youth workers shouldn't see this mystery as troublesome?
RB: It's a reality, so embrace it and celebrate it. N.T. Wright tells his students that a third of what he tells them isn't true, but he doesn't know which third.
So what are your thoughts on this interview? I have my own thoughts on this, but I want to hear yours.
10 comments:
I agree with Rob Bell's focus on spiritual health as opposed to numbers. It's not an easy sell. Many people will evaluate the strength of the youth ministry (or the church as a whole) based upon attendance. Most youth ministries that I've been a part of and observed over the years have focused almost exclusively on the social aspect. No wonder that so many leave the church. If the goal is fun, there are lots better places to look.
I also agree with Bell's emphasis on the Sabbath. I'm not there, yet. Still addicted to my technology. However, I did read a good book a few years ago that has helped me in this area: "Margin" by Richard A. Swenson. He's a Christian medical doctor who emphasizes the importance of leaving space in our lives, like the margins on a page. Well worth the read.
Thanks for the comment Jon . . . I really liked his comment on Sabbath too, something that I am horrible at, but the more I read about it and hear stories, the more I believe that practicing the Sabbath is something that could truly save our spiritual lives, that could renew and refuel us. I've heard him speak in this topic before and he said that implementing the Sabbath was one of the hardest disciplines he's ever done, but it also is one of the best he's ever done. Maybe I'll have to check out Swenson's book.
I can so relate to the part "if you're busy, fried & a wreck, who wants your gospel?" . . .since I often mind myself here. I recently found a note a girlfriend sent me . . .actually just the other night in the middle of the kitchen floor while I was picking up (I have no idea how it got there - but it happened to be just exactly what I needed!)
anyway it was from Bible study . . .it goes like this:
"We are called to do the works of Him who sent us while the opportunity is here. God has foreordained good works for us to accomplish & directs us to them as We ask Him to do so. Beware of doing any good work that God has not planned for you to do. If we are overly busy doing works - however good - that He has not planned for us, we will experience frustration. (substitute feeling fried & a wreck!?!?) Also we will not even see the particular work He, in His sovereign purpose, has planned for us, let alone have time to fit it into an over-burdened schedule. Let us take care lest by being "busy, busy," we get out of God's purpose for our lives & fail to do the particular works He has foreordained for us."
I want my life to reflect His presence so much . . .but often times I try to do so much that it becomes counter-productive! I cram so much into my day that I end up exhausted & overwhelmed.
I don't know ~ these are just my thoughts & sharing as they seem to relate to this conversation.
This is my very first blogging experience - not even sure if I am doing this right! :)
thanks for the comment Kim, congrats on your first blog experience! and you did it right :)
I agree that discipleship is a key element of Youth Ministry, as it was of Jesus' ministry. But we also have to beware of creating a Christian sub-culture when we withdraw into our own lingo, music, and etc. Jesus did not call us to be sub-cultural, he calls us to be counter-cultural, so discipleship is just one element of an effective program. Jesus focused on His on relationship with God, His disciples, but also preached to the masses, fed them, healed, and more. And all the while he fought those who held a staunch, but erroneous view of what true religion is.
I like what Rob has to about say interiors being the real issue and not exteriors. I believe that when Jesus spoke of this, he was not saying to only work on the interior, but that in order for a bowl to be clean, BOTH the inside and the outside must be clean. So big numbers do not necessarily mean authenticity, but then neither do small numbers. What matters is how is Christ portrayed throughout the ministry.
"The harvest is plentiful, but the workers are few. Ask the Lord of the harvest, therefore, to send out workers into his harvest field." Amen. Interestingly, he doesn't instruct us to get busy to work and try to do all the work ourselves. Similarily, Jesus stayed within a small radius during his ministry and poured most of his time into dicipling the twelve. Think about this, Jesus, who is all powerful and could have easily had thousands of diciples, limited himself to twelve?? I find that fascinating! Yes, he taught publicly and healed many, but, when teaching he generally weeded out the crowds by talking in parables and using phrases that made people question him so that he could devote himself to those that were truly interested and willing to ask the tough questions and make the sacrifices he was calling them to make. We would be wise to follow his example, devote ourselves to a few and pour our lives fully into encouraging, teaching and serving the ones that God has placed before us. Numbers, whether small or large, are only numbers. Lives changed and God glorified should be our ultimate goal. I can honestly say, that as a product of a numbers driven youth ministry, I thought the ultimate goal of the gospel was for me to attend as many things as possible and listen only to Christian music and attend Christian concerts, conferences, and invite my friends to do the same. I had no idea that this thing called dicipleship meant to devote oneself to another to mentor them to be servants. I didn't learn that until college. I had no idea and am still learning what discipleship looks like because growing up, I never experienced it. I suppose looking at the example from scripture, if we are wanting more [authentic] numbers, we need more workers so we can serve more students. Let us pray for the Lord to send out workers!
Good thoughts Dusten, but we need to be careful about picking and choosing which examples of Jesus we are going to follow, and which we dismiss. We like the idea of discipling, but what about not having a place to lay your head (Mt 8:20), fasting for 40 days in the wilderness prior to entering ministry (Mt 4:1), etc. Is a preacher who leaves a small radius of ministry wrong for doing so? I hope we would answer, "Of course not!"
Jesus tells us to go into all the world and make disciples. (Mt 28:19-20) Interestingly, he doesn't say how to do it. He doesn't say only one on one, one on 12, only in small groups, etc.
Making disciples is a process that involves us going into the world and living to glorify God, and being able to explain to others our reasonableness of our faith and actions.(Phil. 4:4-5) We plant in a variety of means, but God causes the growth (1 Co 3:6). God has gifted some to do that as Jesus did, in small group discipling. Others he has gifted as evangelists, others as teachers and so on (Eph 4:11). We certainly cannot focus on one type of ministry. A congregation of 200 or 2,000 would not hire a minister to only disciple a few. But perhaps he institutes small groups through his gift of administration.
Numbers are only numbers, but to limit God by focusing on only one aspect or type of ministry does not seem the answer.
BTW, I totally agree with the thought of teaching the tough teachings to weed out the dead weight. I too grew up in a "numbers/activity driven Youth Group," and wish that group had a broader focus. But there has to be a place for those who are searching too.
More thoughts...
When Jesus asks us to pray for workers for the harvest, it is when he sends out the 72. So where did Jesus get 72, if he only invested in 12? Could each of the 12 have had 6 of their own disciples? (Math solution) Not likely, as these men were FAR from being ready to disciple others, as they still did not get it! Jesus must have invested, perhaps to a lesser degree, in the lives of others.
I cannot look at the life of Jesus and see as you do, that he only invested himself in a few. He invited many, invested in many, and made disciples of many. Yes, he strongly invested in the 12, and he did that even knowing that one of them would betray him! That, I find amazing!
So to say that Jesus limited himself to 12 is highly suspect. Also, to say that he taught in parables to weed out the crowd in order to spend more time with the 12 is also suspect. He taught in parables to reveal hidden things, he taught the hard teachings because they were truth, and he was not worried about offending those who were only seeking to feed their own egos or themselves. If Jesus wanted to only invest in the 12, why the miracles and all the attention? Why, in one hour, heal many of diseases and plagues and evil spirits, and on many who were blind bestow sight? (Lk 7:21)
I think what happens sometimes is that when we see something we know is wrong (numbers driven youth ministry), we swing the pendulum all the way over to the other side and say that we will not do anything that hints of that type of ministry. And I think that is a mistake.
i think what we're all trying to say, tim, is that we encourage you in your endeavors to minister to kids, whether it's 2 or 200. we're on this journey with you and since we ourselves are not Jesus, ministering and discipling (sp?) even 12 would be considered worth our every breath. to God be the glory if we reach 200 or 2000, which is entirely possible if we give ourselves as complete vessels. i think that's the point we're all trying to make:)
I think too often we spend time trying to figure out WHAT Jesus would have done and not enough time doing his works. As long as I am living and loving like Jesus I know that others will see it and be able to see Jesus in me. In the end of it all, love wins and Jesus is love.
From the conversations that have happened recently in our life group on Sunday nights I can see that Jesus is being taught and Jesus is being lived out.
"...I have come to give life and give it to the fullest." John 10:10 This is the scripture I keep in mind while I do the works of Jesus and disciple those that he has brought into my life.
Post a Comment